February 21, 2020

U.S. Actively Managed Large-Cap Funds Remain in Secular Decline

by Tom Roseen.

For the fund-flows week ended February 19, 2020, investors were once again net redeemers of large-cap funds (including ETFs), withdrawing a net $3.1 billion. Large-cap mutual funds witnessed net outflows of $2.3 billion, while their ETF counterparts handed back some $752 million. Looking back to 2019, we see that large-cap funds were the pariahs of the equity universe, handing back a net $66.2 billion for the year, their third largest net outflows on record.

However, the headline numbers are a little misleading. Despite the average large-cap fund (+29.80%) posting eye-popping returns for 2019, large-cap mutual funds suffered net redemptions of $98.1 billion, while their ETF counterparts enjoyed net inflows of $31.9 billion. For January 2020, the trend continues, with large-cap funds suffering net redemptions of $17.5 billion and large-cap ETFs attracting $4.6 billion.

Total net assets in large-cap funds have been in secular decline since the beginning of the new millennium, but the outflows from large-cap funds are not offset by the inflows into large-cap ETFs. As I have stated in other segments, I really don’t think this is a case of investors just turning away from actively managed large-cap funds in favor of passive management, but really a case of diversification. Collectively, large-cap funds still account for about 11.1% ($2.8 trillion) of all the open-end fund assets under management in the U.S. ($25.9 trillion as of Dec. 31), with large-cap mutual funds (excluding S&P 500 funds and ETFs) accounting for $2.4 trillion of that sum, and their ETF brethren making up the rest.

While passively managed funds and ETFs have become a popular choice for investors, actively managed large-cap funds’ total assets under management are half the total for the entire ETF market ($4.4 trillion in the U.S., including bond ETFs and equity ETFs).

As part of most Baby Boomers’ core and satellite asset allocation scheme, large caps became disproportionately too big a piece of the pie. As a result, RIAs are now having their clients reallocate from large-cap funds to other non-correlated asset types, such as fixed income funds and nondomestic equity funds.

Get In Touch


We have updated our Privacy Statement. Before you continue, please read our new Privacy Statement and familiarize yourself with the terms.×